Part 14 (the finale) of She Magnifies the Lord: Why Catholic Devotion to Mary Leads Us to Christ

A Catholic response to common objections about Mary, Scripture, the Church, and the Communion of Saints

 New to the series? Start here: Before We Talk About Mary, We Need to Talk About Truth

Missed the previous article?
Read it here: Does the Bible Forbid Prayer to Mary?

Throughout this series, one question has governed every article: does Catholic devotion to Mary lead away from Christ, or does it draw us more deeply into the mystery of who Christ is and what He has accomplished?

We began by examining how the Church receives truth through Scripture, Sacred Tradition, and the Magisterium, because no Marian doctrine can be understood rightly when it is separated from the faith as a whole. From there, we followed Mary through Scripture and the Church’s teaching: as Mother of God and the New Eve; as the Mother given to the beloved disciple from the Cross; as the woman praying with the Church in the Upper Room; as Queen within the Kingdom of her Son; as the woman clothed with the sun; and as the first disciple who heard the word of God and kept it.

We also distinguished the honor given to Mary from the worship owed to God alone, Christ’s unique mediation from the dependent intercession of His members, and the Church’s actual teaching from the caricatures often raised against it. At every step, the same pattern emerged. Every dignity Mary possesses comes from Christ, depends upon Christ, and leads back to Christ.

One final examination remains. A faithful defense of Catholic teaching must also be willing to look inward. Can Catholic speech about Mary become imprecise, excessive, sentimental, or careless? Can devotion be expressed as though Mary were a parallel source of grace, or as though Jesus needed to be persuaded to show mercy? And can fear of those errors lead Catholics into the opposite mistake, minimizing the place Christ has truly given His Mother?

As this series draws to its close, we must reject both distortions and return to the measure Mary herself gives us: does our understanding of her magnify the Lord?

I. The Church Before My Own View

First, I do not disagree with the Church’s Marian dogmas or with the Church’s authentic doctrine about Mary. I submit my own judgment to what the Church has received, guarded, and authoritatively teaches. If I struggle to understand something, the first conclusion I should draw is not that the Church is wrong, but that I may need to be taught more deeply.

I say that from experience, not as a slogan. There have been teachings and prudential judgments from the Church that I have wrestled with. I once struggled with the Church’s current teaching on the death penalty, and more recently I wrestled with the Church’s position amid the recent military conflict, specifically the war in Iran, where she is calling for peace, dialogue, and restraint. I did not arrive at peace with those teachings instantly. I had to pray, study, examine my own instincts, and ask whether my first reaction was being shaped more by politics, fear, anger, or national loyalty than by the mind of Christ as taught through His Church. Over time, I came not merely to accept the Church’s position, but to cherish it, because I began to see that the Church was not weakening justice; she was defending the dignity of the human person and the moral limits Christ places on power.

II. When Catholic Words Fall Short

Now, I do disagree with the way some Catholics sometimes speak about Mary. I disagree when Marian language becomes imprecise, excessive, sentimental, or careless. I disagree when Catholics speak as though Mary were a parallel source of grace, or as though Jesus were distant and Mary had to make Him merciful. I disagree when devotion to Mary is presented in a way that seems to terminate in Mary rather than leading through her to deeper obedience to Christ.

That is not the Church’s doctrine. That is precisely the kind of distortion the Church’s doctrine protects us from. Lumen Gentium §60 says Mary’s role “in no way obscures or diminishes” Christ’s unique mediation, but shows its power. Lumen Gentium §62 says her titles must be understood so that they neither take away anything from nor add anything to the dignity and efficacy of Christ the one Mediator. CCC 970 repeats the same principle. So when Catholic language fails to meet that standard, the problem is not that the Church has taught too much about Mary. The problem is that Catholics have not spoken with the precision the Church herself requires.

I also disagree when Catholics treat Protestant concerns with contempt. Many Protestants raise objections to Marian doctrine because they are trying, however imperfectly, to protect the glory of Christ. I believe they often misunderstand the Catholic position, and I believe Protestant methods of reading Scripture can exclude the Catholic answer before it is even heard. But that does not mean their concern for Christ’s unique glory should be mocked. It should be answered.

III. Two Errors, One Rule

At the same time, I disagree with Catholics who become so embarrassed by Protestant objections that they quietly minimize what the Church teaches. That is not fidelity either. We do not honor Christ by being ashamed of what His Church teaches. We honor Christ by receiving the teaching rightly, explaining it clearly, and ensuring that every Marian title is understood in dependence upon Him.

So my disagreement is not with Mary’s titles, rightly understood. My disagreement is with distortion in either direction: with exaggeration that makes Mary seem independent from Christ, and with fear that strips Mary of the dignity Christ Himself gave her.

The Catholic answer is not less Mary in order to protect Jesus. The Catholic answer is Mary rightly understood within the mystery of Jesus. When Mary is separated from Christ, devotion becomes distorted. But when Mary is seen in Christ, through Christ, and for Christ, she does what she has always done: she magnifies the Lord.

IV. Meet the Church at Its Source

This has been a long series, and it has asked readers to consider a great deal at once. No one is wrong to wrestle with how the Catechism relates to Scripture. No one is wrong to desire the truth of the Catholic faith rather than vague religious language.

The final appeal, then, is to wrestle with what the Church actually teaches, not with a caricature of it. In the words of St. Paul, "work out your salvation in fear and trembling" (Philippians 2:12). Do not wrestle with the claim that Mary is divine, because the Church does not teach that. Do not wrestle with the claim that Mary replaces Christ, because the Church condemns that. Do not wrestle with the claim that Mary’s intercession exists because Jesus is distant or insufficient, because that is the opposite of the Church’s doctrine. Wrestle instead with the actual sources: Scripture, the Catechism, Lumen Gentium, the Fathers, the liturgy, and the saints who loved Mary precisely because she led them more deeply into Christ.

The Catechism’s Marian teaching is not floating in the air. It is sourced. It is tied to John 19, Acts 1, Luke 1, Revelation 12, the Davidic kingdom, the Communion of Saints, the Church’s liturgy, the Council Fathers, and the saints. That does not mean every question disappears immediately. It does mean the Church has not invented her view of Mary out of nothing, nor has she placed Mary beside Christ as His rival.

V. Every Title Leads to Christ

If anything, the Catholic teaching on Mary only makes sense when Christ is made larger, not smaller. Christ is the eternal Son who became man. Christ is the Head of the Body. Christ is the Bridegroom of the Church. Christ is the restored Davidic King. Christ is the one Mediator. Christ is the Redeemer. Christ is the source of every grace Mary ever received and every grace she can ever help us receive. Every authentic Marian doctrine depends entirely on Him.

That is why the safest way to understand Mary is not to isolate her from Christ, and not to be embarrassed by her place in Christ’s mystery, but to see her where Scripture and the Church place her: at the Annunciation, receiving the Word of God in faith; at Cana, directing servants to obey her Son; at the Cross, standing with Him in suffering; in the Upper Room, praying with the Church before Pentecost; and in heavenly glory, as a sign of what Christ intends to accomplish in all the redeemed.

So my final answer is simple: Mary does not compete with Christ. Properly understood, every Marian title is derivative from Christ, dependent upon Christ, and ordered back to Christ. She is Mother of the Church because Christ is Head of the Church. She is Queen because Christ is King. She intercedes because Christ’s one mediation is powerful enough to make His members participants in His love. She is honored because Scripture says all generations will call her blessed. And when she is honored rightly, she does what she has always done: she magnifies the Lord.

VI. Keep Asking

So keep asking questions. Ask them from within the Church, with the Church, and toward the fullness of truth Christ entrusted to her. Test everything, as St. Paul says, but test it according to the whole deposit of faith, not according to a method that has already decided the Catholic answer cannot be true. If the Church’s teaching seems difficult, bring that difficulty to the Church. Let her sources speak before allowing her critics to define her.

No reader should accept this explanation merely because I wrote it. The invitation is to examine what the Church actually teaches, pray with it, test it honestly, and ask whether it leads away from Christ or more deeply into Him. Whenever possible, seek guidance from a faithful spiritual advisor within the Church. My conviction, after wrestling with this myself, is that Mary never takes anything from Jesus. She shows us what His grace can accomplish in a human soul that receives Him completely.

Thank You

Thank you to all who have taken the time to read this article, and especially to those who have stayed with me throughout the entire series. I pray that the Lord will continue to deepen your faith, that this work will edify you, and that all those in your life may encounter, through you, the faith working through love.

Closing Request

Before leaving this series, spend a moment in personal prayer. Is there someone in your life who might benefit from this article or from another article in the series? Ask the Holy Spirit to bring that person to mind and to guide you toward the article he or she may need.

Take a single minute, here, if you will asking the Holy Spirit for this guidance.

Now, if you received a prompting, do as St. Paul instructed us and "test all things; hold fast what is good." Then act upon it. Send that article to the individual, or to each person, whom the Lord places upon your heart.

With that, I ask that we close in prayer together.

Most Holy Virgin Mary, Mother of God and Mother of the Church, intercede for us before your Son, our Lord Jesus Christ. You who received the Word of God in perfect faith, who stood at the Cross without turning away, who prayed with the Church before the Spirit descended, pray for us now, that we may receive the fullness of what your Son has entrusted to His Body. Lead us, as you have always led, not to yourself, but to Him.

Good Saint Joseph, guardian of the Holy Family and patron of the Universal Church, intercede for us. You who protected the Word made flesh in silence and fidelity, who obeyed without fully understanding, who trusted when the mystery exceeded your sight, pray for us, that we may guard what Christ has given us with the same quiet faithfulness you showed in Nazareth and in Egypt and in every hidden moment of your holy life.

Lord Jesus Christ, hear the intercession of your Mother and Your foster father. You who honored Mary from the Cross by giving her to Your Church, You who were obedient to Joseph in the years of your hidden life, receive these petitions as an act of trust in Your mercy and Your will.

Heavenly Father, hear us. We come to You through Your Son, in the communion of Your saints, held together by the grace of Baptism and the bond of the one faith. You are the source of every good thing this series has sought to express. Where it has fallen short, correct it. Where it has pointed toward truth, let that truth take root in the hearts of those who read it. All we ask is that Your will be done, and that Your Son be magnified.

Come, Holy Spirit, Advocate, Paraclete, Spirit of Truth. You who proceed from the Father and the Son, You who hovered over the waters at creation and descended as tongues of fire at Pentecost, You who have guided the Church through every age and every controversy and every moment of confusion, teach us. Remind us of everything He has told us. Lead us into the fullness of truth He has entrusted to His Church, our Church, His Bride, our Mother, she in whom we are so blessed to call Home. Let no pride, no fear, no inherited assumption, no political loyalty, no wounded history stand between any soul and the fullness of the truth Christ died to give. Where we have been wrong, correct us. Where we have been faithful, sustain us. And bring us, at the last, to the Father, through the Son, in the unity of Your love.

Amen.

Now, go forth and do as we hear at the close of Mass, proclaiming the Gospel of the Lord.

Thanks be to God!

_{© Copyright 2026 Matthew Fumi. All Rights Reserved.}