Tu es Petrus: The Papacy as Instituted by Christ
The battle between good and evil has been going on since the dawn of man. This perpetual conflict has been recorded in the Old Testament writings, as well as in the Gospels. Every type of conflict imaginable is in there: person vs. person, person vs. self, person vs. nature, person vs. society and person vs. the supernatural (the devil). The way to resolve such conflicts can only come about by adhering to goodness, by way of the truth. For Christians, this truth is the revealed truth of Jesus Christ, true God and true Man. As He himself stated: “I am the Way, the Truth and the Life” (John, 14:6).
Subjectivity, the proclamation of one’s own version of the truth, is insidious, and thus harmful, because of the sheer hypocrisy it entails. Insidiousness is the quality of causing harm slowly and secretly. Hiding one’s real intention, destroying from within while seemingly wanting to help and inform, is the modus operandi of the hypocrites. Hypocrisy is a lack of transparency, usually perfected to hoodwink people into believing something that is false. Hypocrisy and insidiousness can be found in the media, who are basically controlling the narrative and are undermining objective truth. The media, and news networks in particular, are masters at directing the way their audiences should think. It boils down to verbal engineering, to effect social engineering, to paraphrase author Ruth Marker, who co-wrote about this concept back in 1996, in her article The Art of Verbal Engineering. And, as communications expert Marshall McLuhan said in 1964: “The medium is the message”. In other words, the media dictates exactly which message the population is being fed.
Being subjective and relativistic includes the art of deception; either deceiving oneself or others in a misguided attempt to justify one’s philosophy or agenda, to gain an advantage of some kind. Whether the advantage is monetary gain, power over others or a sincere belief in promulgating an ideology, subjectivism will always be in opposition to truth.
Truth vs Subjectivity
Clinging to truth presupposes an understanding of objectivity, and a natural attraction to goodness. The truth is the truth no matter what anyone says. Someone who talks about “their own truth” is falling into the abyss of subjectivity and is therefore in danger of falling prey to concepts which are the opposite of objective reality (such as “changing one’s sex” or the baby in the womb being just a “sac of cells”).
Stated plainly, society is being manipulated into believing lies, because the lies are being presented as good and true, pandering to the feelings and desires of an overly self-indulgent clientele.
Such ideologies as transgenderism, “death with dignity” (euthanasia), “reproductive rights” (abortion), LGBTQ issues, DEI, etc. are all presented as a good and necessary reality that must become the norm of society. If the agenda-driven proponents of these ideologies were to proclaim these concepts plainly, without relativistic language, they would automatically be exposed as the lies and evil deeds that they truly are; nobody would jump on their bandwagon in such a case. Hence, they hypocritically present their ideas as good and virtuous. For example, if abortion would have truthfully been called by its deed, killing a pre-born baby, instead of being presented as a “reproductive health care right,” it would perhaps not have been so widely accepted.
The way of truth
Catholicism does not condone hypocrisy, nor insidiousness. Following the teachings of Our Lord and Saviour Jesus-Christ, who abhorred hypocrisy, and often called out the hypocrites for their subterfuges, is the way of truth and life. Did he not tell us that our yes should mean yes, and our no should mean no; anything else comes from the evil one (Matthew 5:37).
The Catechism of the Catholic Church states that we must guard “against duplicity, dissimulation and hypocrisy” (Paragraph 2468) and that “The disciple of Christ consents to ‘live in the truth’... If we say we have fellowship with him while we walk in darkness, we lie and do not live according to the truth” (Paragraph 2470).
Indeed, the evil one must be rubbing his hands with glee at the sheer complacency of the population willing to let itself be led astray on the say-so of a few movers and shakers who want to further their own goals. Let us therefore follow Jesus Christ, who is the way, the truth and the life.
Author’s Note: This is the revised and abridged version of the original Sept 24th, 2025 article “The Insidiousness of Subjectivity” posted on the author’s Blog.