As Catholics We Have A Duty to Inform Ourselves Correctly About Current Events
Somewhere between 15 and 25 million men, women and children came into the U.S. through the open border policies of the Biden administration, January 2021 - January 2025. During the first half of that term, everyone agreed that these entries were illegal since they avoided the long-prescribed legal authentication process of admtting immigrants into the country; statements to that effect by leading Democrats during the Obama years are often re-played over the airwaves today. However, in 2023 Biden suddenly declared these entries to be 'legal.' He also stated that these immigrants were all being vetted. Those claims can be investigated and debated in a later discussion, but here I simply wish to examine the repercussions of bringing in such large and unplanned numbers of people into the country in so short a time. I also want to address the disparity of information being put out today by politicians, the media, concerned citizens' groups and even leaders of the Catholic Church. I will apply the term 'illegal immigrant' to any person entering the country in a way that avoids the long-established legal process of immigration through our official ports of entry. I realize that some people choose to avoid this expression and disparage it; however, since the term was universally used for many decades, it is appropriate for this analysis.
How It Began
Historically, illegal immigration began over 70 years ago when owners of large American farms hired migrant Mexican workers on a seasonal basis. These migrants would illegally enter the U.S. two or three times each year, work for a small income and return to Mexico to support their families with their earnings. For decades the government turned a blind eye as there was little perceived harm. But eventually hotels, casinos, landscaping companies, restaurants and other businesses adopted the same practice, greatly increasing the number and duration of these illegal excursions. Over time this led to significant harmful developments: good hard-working Americans, especially those with lower skill levels, were finding it more and more difficult to find jobs.
Even worse, nations adversarial to the U.S. began using our 'soft border' for their own nefarious purposes, as adversaries often will do. Studies now reveal that over the past several years China, Cuba, Venezuela and other Communist countries pushed millions of their own citizens into the United States for the express purpose of overloading our health care, educational and social support systems in order to strain our economy and stir up civil unrest here. Investigative journalist Peter Schweizer gives extensive analysis of this in his well-annotated book, The Invisible Coup (2026).
Strains on Housing
Twenty million people is one-sixteenth of the entire legal U.S. population, the equivalent of another New York State. Such a large, unplanned population increase in just a few years has put tremendous strains on our housing, schools, medical facilities, government benefits programs and job markets. Economists and housing officials calculate that for every 1 million new migrants, the cost of housing goes up by 1 per cent -- a 20% increase for 20 million. Do mainstream news outlets refer to this factor in their 'affordability' discussions? Not that I can see.
How Many Are 'Violent Criminals'?
While a good number of these illegal immigrants are peaceable people who simply took advantage of a U.S. President welcoming them for reasons that are not fully understood,* there's no doubt that many others are not nearly so benign. Schweizer explains how Cuban and Venezuelan leaders in particular were ridding themselves of millions of their criminal and/or mentally ill citizens in this way, and that serious crimes of all types are now being committed by them in the U.S. While the percentage of illegal immigrants who are 'violent criminals' quoted by the media and politicians is 14 per cent, the real number is much worse, due to the official definition of 'violent crime:' It does not include many of the crimes that most of us would expect: distributing drugs, putting out child sexual-abuse material (CSAM), DUI incidents, domestic abuse, theft, etc. Assistant Secretary for DHS Tricia McLaughlin recently told CBS News, “Drug trafficking, distribution of child pornography, burglary, fraud, DUI, embezzlement, solicitation of a minor, human smuggling are all categorized as non-violent crimes.” If these crimes were included, the percentage of illegals who are also violent criminals here would be much, much higher.
Are Our Bishops Compassionate, Naive, or Something Else?
I am a life-long Catholic. I will always love the Catholic Church and always be one of her faithful sons. And knowing her as I do, I understand that the Church is both divinely instituted and inspired and made up of fallible and sinful human beings -- people with varying degrees of knowledge and of holiness. I have seen Catholic bishops and even popes address some very significant issues of the world's nations with a disappointingly superfical and theoretical approach. They frequently discuss critically important matters involving national sovereigny and national security in disturbingly tepid theological language, refusing to acknowledge the existence of extremely dangerous geopolitical forces operating in the world today such as Communism, globalism and Islamic jihad. Our bishops' repeated calls for 'unity' and 'working together' indicates an amazing ignorance of the basic fact that two factions can never work together as long as one is absolutely committed to destroying what the other is totally dedicated to preserving. This lack of wisdom and circumspection is frustrating for many of us.
Does the Holy Father not realize that the United States is not limitless in its ability to take in migrants? Do our U.S. bishops fail to see that the addition of 20 million new migrants in just a few years necessarily deprives good American citizens of the critical goods and services which they voted for and dutifully paid for with their federal, state and local taxes (housing, classrooms, medical care and job opportunities)? How can wise bishops reject the fact that good governance is established in a nation in order to provide for its own citizens first of all -- and then for whatever legal immigrants it can support? The United States of Amercia has always been a nation of charitable people with extremely generous policies towards the less fortunate; but do these Church officials look upon us instead as some kind of 'charitable institution' having no national identity? We are a nation made up largely of good Christian people; do they see us instead as some extension of the Church?
But what is perhaps most troubling is the fact that the amount of money that the USCCB's Catholic Relief Services and Catholic Charities organizations received from the Biden Adminstration as NGOs handling the incoming and settling of these illegal immigrants here amounted to hundreds of millions of dollars! Investigations by Schweizer and many others even reveal that hundreds of thousands of these migrants, leaving their countries for purely economic reasons, were coached by NGOs including Catholic Charities to lie to border officials about needing asylum in order to gain entry here -- thus earning the NGOs their fees for services rendered.
Charity is one thing; receiving great sums of money for a service is something else. But when that service directly contramands the Constitution and laws of the nation, it is yet something else altogether.
----
* Much evidence points to the Biden Administration's intentions of turning them into illegal, non-citizen voters for his political party: Public Interest Legal Foundation, True The Vote, NY Citizens Audit and Unite 4 Freedom are just some of the high-level data-based research groups that have been studying voter identity fraud for many years, and are now claiming that many of these new immigrants are in fact voting.