Teen Book Review - Playing By Heart

Playing By Heart by Carmela Martino

This beautifully written Young Adult novel centers around the strong faith of two sisters, Emilia and Maria, and their extraordinary talents. The book, set in 18^th Century Milan, Italy, focuses on their relationships with their father, as well as their struggle to follow the paths they believe God wants them to take. They lived in a time when young women were subject to their father’s wishes. Unfortunately, their father was not interested in their desires but hoped to showcase their incredible gifts to advance himself to nobility.

The author's beautiful descriptions bring the book to life. I found the passages describing Emilia’s music particularly lovely. Martino also does a wonderful job of showing society and culture of 18^th century Italy. This time period makes for a very interesting book, especially for young women, to see the choices and educational opportunities available to girls their age at that time in history.

This book also highlights something that’s near and dear to my heart – that we all have gifts from God and we should find ways to use these gifts to help others. I loved that these young women knew their talents were from God and they longed to use them in a positive way. I also think the underlying passages of jealousy is something we all can relate to, feeling envious of another’s successes. How Emilia deals with this and works through it is a wonderful example for readers to emulate.

This historic fiction, inspired by two real sisters who lived in 18^th Century Italy, would make a fantastic book club or classroom choice, full of many great topics for discussion. 

Book Description

In this novel from Vinspire Publishing, Emilia Salvini dreams of marrying a man who loves music as much as she does. But in 18th-century Milan, being the "second sister" means she'll likely be sent to a convent instead. Emilia's only hope is to prove her musical talents crucial to her father's quest for nobility. First, though, she must win over her music tutor, who disdains her simply for being a girl. But before she can carry out her plan, a tragedy sends the family into mourning. In her sorrow, Emilia composes a heartrending sonata that causes the maestro to finally recognize her talent. He begins teaching her music theory alongside Antonio Bellini, the arrogant great-nephew of a wealthy marquis. Emilia's feelings toward her rival gradually change as she strives to outdo him. But just when her dreams seem within reach, Emilia learns that her success could destroy not only her future but her sister's very life. Playing By Heart has been awarded numerous book awards.

Amazon Link

Carmela Martino's website

A Note from the Reviewer:

As a writer and a mother, I’m always searching for wonderful Catholic books for teens of all ages. I truly believe one way we can encourage teens in their faith is through fiction with positive messages, embedded in great stories. There are many fantastic Catholic teen novels out today, but they can be hard to find. I’m excited to share some of these books with you. www.LesleaWahl.com